Looking to spend more time on the water without buying a boat? You have two main options: renting boats or joining a boat club. Each choice offers unique benefits for different types of boaters.
A boat club membership gives you regular access to multiple boats for a fixed monthly fee, while boat rentals let you pay only when you want to use a boat. The choice between these options depends on how often you plan to go boating and what kind of experience you want on the water.
Boat clubs work best if you want to boat several times a month. You’ll pay more upfront than rentals, but the cost per trip goes down the more you use it. Rentals give you more flexibility with no long-term commitment, making them perfect for occasional outings or trying different boats.
This post contains affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Thanks.
Key Takeaways
- Boat clubs offer better value for frequent boaters through fixed monthly fees
- Rentals provide more flexibility with pay-per-use pricing and no commitment
- Club memberships include extra perks like maintenance and training while rentals keep it simple
What Is a Boat Club?
A boat club gives you access to a fleet of boats through a membership program. You’ll pay an initial fee to join and then monthly dues for regular boat access.
Members can reserve different types of boats for their outings. You might take a pontoon boat one day and a fishing boat the next.
The club handles all maintenance, cleaning, and storage of the boats. You just show up and enjoy your time on the water.
Many clubs like Freedom Boat Club have locations across multiple states. Your membership often lets you use boats at any club location.
How Does Boat Rental Work?
Boat rental is a pay-per-use system where you rent a boat for a specific time period. You can rent for a few hours, a full day, a weekend, a week, or even longer.
Rental companies typically charge by the hour or day. Prices vary based on the boat size, year, type, and fleet type you choose. Meaning, bareboat, skippered boat, or crewed boat.
You’ll need to pick up and return the boat at set times. Most rental places provide basic safety equipment and a quick orientation.
Unlike a club membership, there’s no long-term commitment. You can rent different boats from various companies whenever you want to get out on the water.
The Pros and Cons
Both boat clubs and rentals give you ways to enjoy time on the water without buying a boat. Each option comes with unique benefits and trade-offs that affect your boating experience and wallet.
Advantages of a Boat Club
Boat clubs give you fast, easy access to a variety of boats. You can try different vessels for fishing, skiing, or cruising without extra costs.
The monthly fee covers insurance, maintenance, and storage. You won’t need to worry about fixing engines or cleaning the boat after use.
Most clubs offer training and support to help you feel confident on the water. Staff members can teach you boat handling and safety skills.
You can often reserve boats online or through an app. Many clubs let you book weeks ahead for special events or weekends.
Benefits of Renting a Boat
Renting gives you complete freedom to boat when and where you want. You don’t need to pay monthly fees or make a long-term commitment.
You can pick boats in different locations during your travels. Many rental companies have spots at popular lakes and beaches.
The cost is clear – you only pay for the time you use. There’s no membership fee or yearly contract to worry about.
Perfect for occasional boaters who go out just a few times per year. You can match your rental to each specific trip or activity.
Downsides to Boat Clubs
Getting a boat on weekdays is easy, but on weekends, it can be tough. Popular times fill up fast, and you might not get your first choice of vessel.
The initial joining fee can be steep. Some clubs charge several thousand dollars to start, plus monthly payments.
Not all clubs maintain their boats well. You might find wear and tear or mechanical issues that affect your day.
Some clubs limit your booking times or put caps on usage. Read the rules carefully to know what’s included.
Challenges of Boat Rental
Rental rates spike during peak seasons. Holiday weekends and summer months bring much higher prices.
Each rental means new paperwork and safety checks. The process takes time away from your day on the water.
Quality varies between rental companies. Some boats might be older or not well maintained.
Last-minute rentals can be hard to find. Popular boats often book up days or weeks in advance, especially in busy areas.
Comparing Costs
Money plays a big role in deciding between joining a boat club or renting boats. Each option comes with different fees and expenses you need to think about.
Membership Fees vs Rental Rates
A boat club costs about several hundred dollars per month, plus a joining fee of hundreds to a few thousand dollars, depending on the boat club. When you break the price down, it becomes cheaper than renting if you plan to go boating more than a few times per month.
Rental rates vary by location and boat size. You might pay $300-$600 and even more for a day out on the water. The good part is you only pay when you use the boat.
Boat clubs include insurance and maintenance in your fees. With rentals, these costs are usually built into the daily rate.
Maintenance and Upkeep Responsibilities
Taking care of a boat requires significant time, effort, and expertise. The level of maintenance responsibility varies greatly between boat clubs and rentals.
Boat Club Maintenance Services
When you join a boat club, you won’t need to worry about maintenance tasks. The club handles all the cleaning, repairs, and seasonal upkeep.
Professional staff members clean each boat after every use. They check the engine, change the oil, and inspect safety equipment regularly.
The club takes care of winterization in cold climates and spring preparation. If something breaks, they fix it right away.
You won’t pay extra for routine maintenance or unexpected repairs. The club covers all these costs in your membership fees.
Managing Boat Rental Maintenance
With boat rentals, you’re not responsible for long-term maintenance. You just need to return the boat in the same condition you received it.
You must clean up any messes you make during your rental period unless you rent a luxury crewed boat, the team will take care of everything (Cooking, cleaning, services, and more). This includes removing trash and wiping down surfaces.
The rental company checks the boat’s condition before and after your trip. They might charge you for any damage that happens while you’re using it.
So, it’s important to report any mechanical issues you notice right away. The rental company needs to know about problems so they can fix them before the next customer.
Final Words!
In conclusion, the decision between a boat rental and a boat club ultimately hinges on your boating habits and preferences.
If you plan to hit the water frequently, a boat club may offer the best value, providing access to a variety of different types of vessels along with additional perks such as training and support.
Conversely, if you’re an occasional boater who values flexibility and spontaneity, renting a boat allows you to enjoy the water without the commitment of a membership.
Want More Tips?
Subscribe to Cruising Sea newsletter to receive every two-week the latest post straight to your inbox!
Daniella has been passionate about travel, the sea, and nature for many years. As a child, she frequently traveled throughout the Mediterranean and continued with her journeys throughout her adult life.
Her experiences have created the desire within her to share her love for traveling with other passionate and adventurers who want to discover beautiful horizons and new cultures.
